Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Media Lies About "Murtha Amendment"
OLD American Century / White Rose Society message boards > Political Discussion forums > Media
shoeless
Hannity falsely referred to Republican resolution as the "Murtha amendment"

On both his television and radio show, Fox News host Sean Hannity referred to a congressional resolution calling for the immediate termination of U.S. troop deployment in Iraq as the "Murtha amendment." But the resolution in question was not sponsored by Rep. John P. Murtha (D-PA). While Murtha had introduced a detailed measure that called for the withdrawal of American forces from Iraq "at the earliest practicable date," his resolution bore little resemblance to the Republican-sponsored measure Hannity was discussing. This one-sentence resolution -- described in news reports as a "political trap" and "aimed at embarrassing war critics" -- simply ordered "that the deployment of United States forces in Iraq be terminated immediately."

Further, Wall Street Journal OpinionJournal.com editor James Taranto falsely wrote that the House of Representatives had voted "on Rep. John Murtha's proposal for an immediate withdrawal from Iraq." In fact, only the GOP measure, sponsored by Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-CA), reached a vote in the House.

http://mediamatters.org/items/200511210009

user posted image
sky of mind
That sorta goes with out saying and should have been expected!
shoeless
QUOTE(sky of mind @ Tuesday, 22 November 2005, 1:29 pm)
That sorta goes with out saying and should have been expected!
[right][snapback]35397[/snapback][/right]


Yes, but if anyone wonders why the Democrats seldom get any traction, this is a perfect example of the problem. All too often, these sort of right-wing lies are endlessly repeated by hacks like Hannity and Limbaugh until the MSM picks up the chant. Soon, the truth is a distant, foggy memory. Notice the WSJ has already begun to repeat the lie.

Keep an eye on this. We'll see how many MSM outlets begin to attribute the Republican bill to John Murtha.
shoeless
OK, now it is turning into a battle between truth and lies.

On the side of honesty we have the LA Times and the Washington Post.

QUOTE
But as the Los Angeles Times reported, Republicans forced a vote not on Murtha's idea but, rather, on a different proposal "intended to fail and aimed at embarrassing war critics." The Washington Post also reported that "[r]ecognizing a political trap, most Democrats -- including Murtha -- said from the start they would vote no."


In the catagory of lying sacks of shit, we have the editorial pages of the Wall Street Journal and the NY Post, and John Gibson of Fox News and Sean Hannity on the ABC Radio Network.

QUOTE
"Why then do you think Murtha's suggestion last week, voted down by the House, is causing so much trouble?"- John Gibson

It doesn't mention that his Iraq pullout plan was actually put to a vote, 403 to 3. Even Murtha didn't vote for his own pullout plan.- Sean Hannity

But Murtha's service doesn't automatically make him right on military strategy. House Republicans made that plain Friday, forcing a vote to show just how little on-the-record support exists, even among Dems, for his idea. The bill called for immediate withdrawal; it went down, 403-3.- NY Post Editorial Nov. 22

"The House of Representatives had voted on Rep. John Murtha's proposal for an immediate withdrawal from Iraq."- Wall Street Journal OpinionJournal.com editor James Taranto

http://mediamatters.org/items/200511220010






sky of mind
The Repugs have known for a long time now and made exceptional use of perception!

It's not about truth or reality!
It's what you can convince the TV generation to be truth!



How many people watch to see who gets kicked off the island
watches the show and thinks these people are actually all alone on the island?

How many completely forget about the production crew?
(Which likely is twice as many people as the original set of people)


We can all watch cartoons and know when Coyote slams into the ground after falling about a mile,
That he's gonna walk away from it.
But how many of us watched Jaws, and feared to swim cause of the sharks?
Even though we were far and away more likely to die in a car!



Perception, and the fact that these Rethugs have no morality issue against twisting the truth into a new, false reality!

That;s why we call them Repugnicans!
shoeless
More lies from Fox News.

Hume, backed by Liasson, falsely claimed that Democrats want to "pull out now" from Iraq
rcorporon
Hannity is lying? Who'd have thought?

Lets time the MSM and see how long it takes to pick up the "murtha mantra"
shoeless
QUOTE(rcorporon @ Wednesday, 7 December 2005, 7:11 pm)
Hannity is lying?  Who'd have thought?

Lets time the MSM and see how long it takes to pick up the "murtha mantra"
[right][snapback]36667[/snapback][/right]


Well Sean Hannity is a pathological liar, but the latest offense was Fox News anchor Brit Hume doing the lying.

The difference is important. While both are shameless Republican political hacks, Brit Hume masquerades as an actual journalist.

user posted image
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.