Deborah
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 5:53 pm
Perhaps if I make my statements on a dedicated thread, readers will find them more easily understandable. The following is my original statement.
| QUOTE |
I had a very interesting experience at the Cannes Film Festival this year. I decided to throw a party to "Celebrate the Human Spirit." It was very well attended and we had to chase people out a couple of hours after it was supposed to have ended. A number of people commented on how nice it was to go to an event that wasn't trying to sell something at that very commercial institution.
A few days later, I went to lunch with a number of attendees who were new to me. We were talking about the party and someone made the comment that I must feel very out of place in America. I replied to the contrary but then asked why he had set that. As the others murmured agreement, he pointed out to me that Americans have made it very obvious that all they care about is money. When I tried to disagree, they explained that this is the image we export to the rest of the world: In our films and television shows, it is overwhelmingly about winning and getting the money; rarely about romance or poetry or religion or politics or intellectual curiosity.
As I listened, I realized that they were absolutely correct. That is an extraordinary thing to me. It horrifies me and I think that the fact that I - who have offices in two different foreign countries, travel a lot, and consider myself fairly cosmopolitan - had never understood this before, is a sign that we may never be considered as members of the world community because, once again, we just don't get it. |
I then speculated about the following:
| QUOTE |
I wonder what effect the institution of slavery and the fact that the red states were willing to secede from the Union rather than give up their slaves has had on a) our national consciousness, our national conscience, and c) our standing in the World. |
Now, can we take it from there, rather from defensiveness?
Just so you know, my family's from Tennessee. I am descended from slave-owners, runaway slaves and Cherokees who refused to be marched to Oklahoma. Rebels, all.
MasterMind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 7:26 pm
I think slavery has played a huge part in our national consciousness, but on a global scale? I dont really think so. I think the idea that all Americans are greedy carries over more. I mean on the grande scheme of the World, we are still very young and their are nations and groups of people out there, who have done far worse then we have.
Now that does not excuse what we did, but nether does bringing it up.
I had nothing to do with slavery and it pissed me off everytime its brought up and its demanded, that as a southerner I have to apologize or even feel sorry about it. I dont feel ether. You have a more direct link to slavery then I do, Deb. Do you think you are resonsible for all the bad slavery acts in America?
So what merrit do you have in saying all of America or even just all of the South took part in this? There is slavery all around the world, so do you blame every human for slavery?
What are you doing to stop modern day Slavery in America? Of the Eastern Block, or in Asia?
If you dont lift a finger for the present you have no right to claim foul about the past.
sky of mind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 7:45 pm
Deb,
I'm not sure I completely understand this multi fascited question, and I am sure my reply will be very insufficient. But I will start the discussion.
First, I don't believe the US was unique in it's slave situation. But the question was about the US, not other countries.
I would have to conclude those actions from that time, roughly 150 years ago, still to this day indicates how the Mason Dixon line displays this division in America.
But then, I live in a Blue state. My perspective is unique with my region. (The North West) I will say though that a couple of decades back I taught Adult Drivers Ed. Most were older women who's husbands had died and now they needed to learn, I mean really learn HOW to drive a car! (Kids don't need to be taught how, they need to be taught how to stay alive!) Any who, one of my students was a black man in his middle 20's. His employeer, the City, decided that driving was a requirement to his job. At 2 hours a lesson that average 6 or 8 lessons, we had quite a few conversations while we drove. Among other things he said he'd rather live in the south! He said, yeah, thems some racist som bitches, but they don't lie about it! They are straight up honest and say it to your face. As apposed to white northerners who smile, shake your hand and tell you how wonderful it is that you get what you got, then get pissy if a black family moves into the neighborhood. I don't know if things have improved much since then for blacks, but I suspect his point was valid then and still is valid today!
Anyway, how does the keeping of slaves in the south, (didnt mention blue state slaves) The souths willingness to break away over the issue of states rights and slavery? That's a lot of question. Though I always thought it was a rich and an abuse of irony for the US to insist that South Africa end Apartheit.
Deborah
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:19 pm
Neither of your responses had anything whatsoever to do with what I wrote. Until you have figured out what I said and have responded in kind, I don't know how to respond to you.
You have jumped to a great many conclusions.
Dave
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:25 pm
| QUOTE (MasterMind @ Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 6:26 pm) |
I think slavery has played a huge part in our national consciousness, but on a global scale? I dont really think so. I think the idea that all Americans are greedy carries over more. I mean on the grande scheme of the World, we are still very young and their are nations and groups of people out there, who have done far worse then we have.
Now that does not excuse what we did, but nether does bringing it up.
I had nothing to do with slavery and it pissed me off everytime its brought up and its demanded, that as a southerner I have to apologize or even feel sorry about it. I dont feel ether. You have a more direct link to slavery then I do, Deb. Do you think you are resonsible for all the bad slavery acts in America?
So what merrit do you have in saying all of America or even just all of the South took part in this? There is slavery all around the world, so do you blame every human for slavery?
What are you doing to stop modern day Slavery in America? Of the Eastern Block, or in Asia?
If you dont lift a finger for the present you have no right to claim foul about the past. |
I think I understand where you're coming from. I also don't think anyone but the most foolhardy would be demanding personal aplogies from you. What is important is to acknowledge the deep and lasting leagacy that 300 years of slavery followed by a 100 years of legal persecution, including official terror has done to a substantial portion of the citizenry.
And it's not just a "southern" thing, there are no borders when it comes to racsim. For example, Indiana, iirc had the largest active KKK org in the entire country at one time.
This country has never officially acknowledged any of the damage done nor does it seem likely to any time soon. Though the wealth of this nation was substantially built on the backs of slaves, indentured servants and resources stolen from its murdered rightful owners, there has been little compensation meted out to the descendants of tehse poor people. And politically that's not possible because that would cost the Plutocrats a pretty penny.
We're a long way from any resolution at all when in 2005, it is politcially impossible for more than 10% of the US Senate to officially comndemn lynching for crissakes.
BTW, I had two ancestors killed fighting in the armies of the seccesh traitors. They were 16 and 18 years old.
Rich man's war, poor man's fight.
MasterMind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:42 pm
Another thing that pisses me off is that this is brought up over and over abotu being about racisim. We are blinded by color, while the rich screw the hell out of us.
It has always been about the extreme wealthy and the poor. There has been illusions of a middle class, but they never really owned anything ether. All over the worlds, no matter what the controled public opinion may be, its always been the haves versus the have nots.
If you want to continue to waste your time on something that only your generation brings up and not fight the GOOD fight, then by all means. But ask people my age about this issue and we dont care. We see racial color, like hair color. Its just a description of someone and that is all it means. I see and feel there is no difference beyond that.
I am not saying it doesnt exist, It does, but I feel with global culture developing rapidly enough, your primitive notion of rasicm will hopefully die with you. I hope so atleast, but not likely in my life time ether.
I am rambling on again and incase you havent figured it out yet, I am a quarter tard.
[Edit-
| QUOTE |
Neither of your responses had anything whatsoever to do with what I wrote. Until you have figured out what I said and have responded in kind, I don't know how to respond to you.
You have jumped to a great many conclusions. |
Umm.... You wrote this....
| QUOTE |
I then speculated about the following:
QUOTE I wonder what effect the institution of slavery and the fact that the red states were willing to secede from the Union rather than give up their slaves has had on a) our national consciousness, cool.gif our national conscience, and c) our standing in the World.
Now, can we take it from there, rather from defensiveness?
Just so you know, my family's from Tennessee. I am descended from slave-owners, runaway slaves and Cherokees who refused to be marched to Oklahoma. Rebels, all. |
Now we both answered the world view portion and we both answered the National Consciousness question.
How can you not say how we both personal feel about this and how we feel our regions feel about it have nothing to do with national consciousness?
Just cause you dont like the answers does not mean we did not answer the questions. I would rather you just say "I dont agree with you, you are wrong" Then that lame answer.
sky of mind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:58 pm
| QUOTE (MasterMind @ Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:42 pm) |
Another thing that pisses me off is that this is brought up over and over abotu being about racisim. We are blinded by color, while the rich screw the hell out of us.
It has always been about the extreme wealthy and the poor. There has been illusions of a middle class, but they never really owned anything ether. All over the worlds, no matter what the controled public opinion may be, its always been the haves versus the have nots.
If you want to continue to waste your time on something that only your generation brings up and not fight the GOOD fight, then by all means. But ask people my age about this issue and we dont care. We see racial color, like hair color. Its just a description of someone and that is all it means. I see and feel there is no difference beyond that.
I am not saying it doesnt exist, It does, but I feel with global culture developing rapidly enough, your primitive notion of rasicm will hopefully die with you. I hope so atleast, but not likely in my life time ether.
I am rambling on again and incase you havent figured it out yet, I am a quarter tard.
[Edit-
| QUOTE | Neither of your responses had anything whatsoever to do with what I wrote. Until you have figured out what I said and have responded in kind, I don't know how to respond to you.
You have jumped to a great many conclusions. |
Umm.... You wrote this....
| QUOTE | I then speculated about the following:
QUOTE I wonder what effect the institution of slavery and the fact that the red states were willing to secede from the Union rather than give up their slaves has had on a) our national consciousness, cool.gif our national conscience, and c) our standing in the World.
Now, can we take it from there, rather from defensiveness?
Just so you know, my family's from Tennessee. I am descended from slave-owners, runaway slaves and Cherokees who refused to be marched to Oklahoma. Rebels, all. |
Now we both answered the world view portion and we both answered the National Consciousness question.
How can you not say how we both personal feel about this and how we feel our regions feel about it have nothing to do with national consciousness?
Just cause you dont like the answers does not mean we did not answer the questions. I would rather you just say "I dont agree with you, you are wrong" Then that lame answer.
|
Deb,
Maybe it would help if you tried rewording the question,
and remember, we ain't to bright so keep it simple?
None of us intends any insults.
And I don't think anyone is jumping to any conclusions!
It the least, we did not intend too.
As I said, we ain't too smart.
Please forgive us?
Dave
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 10:05 pm
| QUOTE (MasterMind @ Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 8:42 pm) |
I am not saying it doesnt exist, It does, but I feel with global culture developing rapidly enough, your primitive notion of rasicm will hopefully die with you. I hope so atleast, but not likely in my life time ether. |
If you are referring to my post and characterizing my notions as "primitive" then clearly, you haven't the slighest idea what I'm talking about nor do you appear cognizant of your limitations.
Causes have effects that linger for centuries. It makes no difference what your all up to date notions of race may be (btw race is an artificial construct invented by white europeans to dress up their chauvinism, imperialism and ignorance with a nice "scientific" veneer) the societal and cultural effects are enormous and impact each and every individual alive today, especially those descended from the enslaved.
sky of mind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 10:08 pm
Dave,
Maybe it's the hot weather.
Seems many of us wanna

a lot!
MasterMind
Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 10:25 pm
I wasnt talking to you Dave, but nice answer. I agree with you, it has molded our culture, alot. But I didnt have a hand in it and I dont want any part of it is what it boils down to.
Dave
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 12:52 am
| QUOTE (MasterMind @ Tuesday, 26 July 2005, 9:25 pm) |
| I wasnt talking to you Dave, but nice answer. I agree with you, it has molded our culture, alot. But I didnt have a hand in it and I dont want any part of it is what it boils down to. |
Good deal then. Understanding is all that's necessary. Personally I don't feel this demand you seem to, to be a part if it
You are certainly entitled to your opinion and I respect that. And you know who the real enemy is. But to a lot of folks, they see it differently. No matter what side of the coin is in power, people of color have been getting the shaft for 400 years now and they sure as hell are aware if it, too. Excuse them if they have some difficulty seeing the real enemy as we do. It wears the same face as it always has.
sky of mind
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 8:40 am
| QUOTE |
| No matter what side of the coin is in power, people of color have been getting the shaft for 400 years now and they sure as hell are aware if it, too. Excuse them if they have some difficulty seeing the real enemy as we do. It wears the same face as it always has. |
Dave,
would it be more accurate to say, "non-white european discent people?"
I mean, Anerican Indians in some cases are doing better, (thanks to casinos) but still get the short stick. Mexicans don't fare so well. Etc.
Deborah
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 8:55 am
I am trying here to discuss our image in the world, everyone else's perception of the United States. Does that help any?
Toshiro Tzu
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 11:11 am
There's nothing to really discuss. Yes we're greedy, and yes the rest of the world sees it, what more's there to say? The national conscience has little to do with slavery and more to do with the constant bombardment of propaganda telling us the good ole US of A is the place to get rich and everyone living here is wealthy when it just ain't so. If you want wealth and living a decent life, you move to Sweden or Holland. If you want struggle in hopes that you're one of the very few who strike it rich, you live here. In the mean time the poor like believe they're rich by buying shit they can't afford and won't pay off for 20+ years while floating checks and living constantly under the thumb of creditors.
sky of mind
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 11:16 am
| QUOTE (Toshiro Tzu @ Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 11:11 am) |
| There's nothing to really discuss. Yes we're greedy, and yes the rest of the world sees it, what more's there to say? The national conscience has little to do with slavery and more to do with the constant bombardment of propaganda telling us the good ole US of A is the place to get rich and everyone living here is wealthy when it just ain't so. If you want wealth and living a decent life, you move to Sweden or Holland. If you want struggle in hopes that you're one of the very few who strike it rich, you live here. In the mean time the poor like believe they're rich by buying shit they can't afford and won't pay off for 20+ years while floating checks and living constantly under the thumb of creditors. |
That Tzu, sure has the ability to be astute!
Hows that Deb?
BTW, once and if the People of the US throw out the robber barons,
perceptions might change.
Won't happen any time soon though.
This country was designed around this social system.
Dave
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 12:21 pm
| QUOTE (sky of mind @ Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 7:40 am) |
Dave,
would it be more accurate to say, "non-white european discent people?" I mean, Anerican Indians in some cases are doing better, (thanks to casinos) but still get the short stick. Mexicans don't fare so well. Etc. |
I think it can all be summed up nicely, regardless of color; The Exploited.
Dave
Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 12:26 pm
| QUOTE (Toshiro Tzu @ Wednesday, 27 July 2005, 10:11 am) |
| There's nothing to really discuss. Yes we're greedy, and yes the rest of the world sees it, what more's there to say? The national conscience has little to do with slavery and more to do with the constant bombardment of propaganda telling us the good ole US of A is the place to get rich and everyone living here is wealthy when it just ain't so. If you want wealth and living a decent life, you move to Sweden or Holland. If you want struggle in hopes that you're one of the very few who strike it rich, you live here. In the mean time the poor like believe they're rich by buying shit they can't afford and won't pay off for 20+ years while floating checks and living constantly under the thumb of creditors. |
Fully agreed and nicely said, Sun.
Given this country's international depredations in service to the Plutocracy while jabbering and lecturing endlessly about "Democracy & Human Rights", the rest of the worls sees us for the ignorant hypocrites we are. The fact there is slavery in our past isn't really in play when the informed world sees rampaging "American" Corporations enslaving people in the third world, constantly.
Of course, what the informed world (ie: Europe) often fails to see is their own countries' part in the same exploitation.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.